Dominik Lukeš
Search/

Discourse analysis

How public, political and media debates are framed and negotiated, and methods for analysing them.

2012 1

2011 4

Konec výmluv?

Writing Lidové noviny · c. 2011 · Journalism

The piece argues that the September 11 attacks no longer justify wars that killed far more civilians and reduced civil liberties across the West.

2010 4

Vládci významu a formy I.: Význam

Writing A2 · c. 2010 · Journalism

The piece argues that social power and context determine which interpretations of an utterance become authoritative.

2009 2

2008 11

Inevitability of understanding: The folk theory

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 23 June 2008 · Blog post

The piece argues that political opponents treat language as producing inevitable conclusions and therefore interpret disagreement as incompetence or corruption.

Unintended consequences of political correctness

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 22 March 2008 · Blog post

The piece argues that political correctness can entrench new linguistic frames that make affirmative racial identification difficult to discuss.

Individual perspicacity, collective naïveté

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 17 February 2008 · Blog post

The piece asks why individuals can recognise manipulative political discourse while collective electoral behaviour often remains predictable.

2007 51

Convention over logic: Limits of implicature

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 14 October 2007 · Blog post

The piece uses an anomalous newspaper reference to suspects to show how journalistic convention can override ordinary pragmatic implicature.

Perspectives, views and child cognition

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 12 September 2007 · Blog post

The piece argues that explanations of the September 11 attacks for children should present competing perspectives explicitly instead of using syntactically simplified but conceptually opaque prose.

Searching for coherence in high-stakes utterances

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 1 September 2007 · Blog post

The piece explains a pageant contestant's incoherent answer as a failed attempt to integrate stock public frames under pressure rather than evidence of low intelligence.

Bill O'Reilly on the 8:05 from Brighton

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 13 August 2007 · Blog post

The piece challenges theories that treat ordinary audiences as cognitively captive to propaganda while exempting trained analysts from the same influence.

Networks of trust and the newspaper business

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 13 August 2007 · Blog post

The piece argues that newspapers may persist as validators within social networks of trust even after printed news disappears.

Anecdotes, metaphors and the negotiated truth

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 11 August 2007 · Blog post

The piece argues that journalistic anecdotes acquire truth through negotiated interpretation and that verification checklists cannot remove this dependence.

Negotiating image projections: Who has the power?

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 23 July 2007 · Blog post

The piece examines how gendered political frames constrain Hillary Clinton's public image while remaining partly open to conscious negotiation.

Negotiating scenarios of democracy

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 13 July 2007 · Blog post

The piece analyses a story of the president as an employee to show how public narratives negotiate duties between citizens and government.

Collective negotiation of causal relations

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 11 July 2007 · Blog post

The piece argues that American opposition to the Iraq war collectively avoids responsibility for the consequences of the invasion.

Language Log: The Supreme Court Fails Semantics

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 8 July 2007 · Blog post

The piece rejects a context-free semantic analysis of a school banner and argues that its anti-establishment meaning arises through shared frames.

Opportunism and power of analogical mapping

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 2 July 2007 · Blog post

The piece shows that historical analogies depend on opportunistic mappings whose aptness must be negotiated against the record.

Generative analogies as negotiation devices

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 30 June 2007 · Blog post

The piece uses the phrase liberal fascism to show how generative analogies are judged through negotiated aptness and credibility rather than truth alone.

Havel on intertextuality

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 14 June 2007 · Blog post

The piece uses Václav Havel's description of political language to examine how verbal patterns spread through cognitive, textual and social processes.

Science vs. social science of the environment

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 14 June 2007 · Blog post

The piece argues that scientific consensus is rhetorical and that science becomes a legitimate political participant when it enters public debate.

Negotiating 'lie'

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 10 May 2007 · Blog post

The piece shows how public discourse negotiates whether political statements qualify as lies and which responses a lie permits.

The analogical instinct

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 8 May 2007 · Blog post

The piece uses reactions to a French presidential campaign to illustrate the political impulse to construct analogies across countries and candidates.

Metaphor hypostasis as a cohesive device

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 27 April 2007 · Blog post

The piece shows how an explicitly named war metaphor organises the imagery and cohesion of an otherwise descriptive political text.

Evidencing negotiated frames: The Pelosi debate

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 7 April 2007 · Blog post

The piece uses commentary on Nancy Pelosi's clothing to show how cultural scenarios provide evidence for frame completion and negotiation.

Framing the frames: The Gingrich gambit

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 4 April 2007 · Blog post

The piece analyses Newt Gingrich's denial of an anti-Spanish remark through the folk frame that bilingual education produces social isolation.

Negotiating vocabulary and the logic of analogy

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 23 March 2007 · Blog post

The piece argues that word meanings and causal analogies are negotiated in discourse rather than supplied as fixed consequences of language.

Sex and race on and beneath the surface of discourse

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 16 February 2007 · Blog post

The piece argues that emphatic slurs do not reliably reveal underlying prejudice and that discourse analysis cannot securely recover an individual text's hidden meaning.

Discursive diglossia and American racial politics

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 4 February 2007 · Blog post

The piece argues that perceptions of articulate Black politicians depend on racialised speech cadences, group membership and unequal social power.

2006 14

Free Market Doctrines: From analogy to ritual

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 17 December 2006 · Blog post

The piece argues that critics of free-market doctrine can reproduce the same ritualised ideological reasoning when they present their own framework as human nature.

Framing the Civil War

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 5 December 2006 · Blog post

The piece analyses the term civil war as a negotiated frame whose descriptive, political, and scalar meanings cannot be separated.

Frame negotiation on the media

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 3 October 2006 · Blog post

The piece uses disputes over calling Iraq a civil war to show how media participants negotiate both descriptions and their political consequences.

Scenarios behind education

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 24 August 2006 · Blog post

The piece argues that education debates negotiate competing images of schooling while overlooking the logistical burden of reform.

Scenarios behind technology and education debate

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 22 August 2006 · Blog post

The piece argues that a story about one student's use of Google Books cannot establish the technology's systemic effect on higher education.

Framing in perceptions of news bias

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 11 August 2006 · Blog post

The piece argues that partisan frames shape perceptions of news bias and that readers can only challenge them through sustained questioning.

Values and statements about education

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 24 July 2006 · Blog post

The piece exposes the market frame that connects national freedom with choice and competition in education policy.

News reporting as a cognitive (speech) act

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 9 January 2006 · Blog post

The piece uses a literal news headline to consider whether reporting can function as a cognitive or social act.

Florida high court kills school voucher program

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 6 January 2006 · Blog post

The piece argues that school vouchers overextend a market metaphor that cannot represent education's multiple participants, purposes, and social consequences.

2005 19

Parents' role in education - framing in practice

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 20 December 2005 · Blog post

The post identifies a radio debate about parental involvement as an example of competing and shifting cognitive models of education.

My Week In Thought and Hermeneutic Suspicion

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 14 December 2005 · Blog post

The post argues that myth-busting and scepticism are themselves narrative forms whose legitimacy must remain open to questioning.

Conceptual integration and the creation of news

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 8 December 2005 · Blog post

The post explains how news formulas structure mental spaces that are blended with events to produce political reporting and argument.

Reliability of common wisdom - models and power

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 8 December 2005 · Blog post

The post compares competing schemas for interpreting scientific consensus and dissent, using obesity and climate change as examples.

Salient cases and social causality

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 8 December 2005 · Blog post

The post compares aggregate and case-based models of media influence and shows how apparently incompatible causal accounts can be reconciled.

Culture wars and personal identity

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 2 December 2005 · Blog post

The post argues that American culture-war participants experience opposing institutions as threats to the validity of their identities and conceptual frames.

Labor's Lost Story

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 29 November 2005 · Blog post

The post highlights how competing narratives about capitalism and labour shape arguments over job losses and social protection.

Turning academia into a cafeteria - Los Angeles Times

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 23 November 2005 · Blog post

The post examines how market language about choice enters academic discourse while questioning broad claims about the damage caused by such language.

Ad-hoc metaphors as cohesive devices

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 22 November 2005 · Blog post

The post identifies an extended political analogy as a cohesive frame that holds an argument together.

The Bosnian Example for Iraq

Writing Hermeneutic Heretic · 21 November 2005 · Blog post

The post examines Bosnia as an analogy for Iraq and asks how private analogies become established structures for public reasoning.

2003 4

Argumenty pro a proti valce

Writing Lidové noviny · c. 2003 · Journalism

The piece argues that the principal justifications offered for invading Iraq do not establish a sufficient case for war.

Kam se poděla válka?

Writing Lidové noviny · c. 2003 · Journalism

The column shows how George W. Bush and Saddam Hussein used metaphor to frame the Iraq War while avoiding or redirecting the word war itself.

Naživo

Writing Lidové noviny · c. 2003 · Journalism

The piece criticises live television coverage that presents the Iraq war as spectacle while concealing the people killed by the weapons it shows.

Válka v tropech

Writing Lidové noviny · c. 2003 · Journalism

The essay explains how metaphors such as war on terror and Saddam as Hitler frame political reasoning and make military action appear necessary.

2001 5

Jak se dělá argument aneb polemický snář

Writing Lidové noviny · c. 2001 · Journalism

The column apologises for insulting Ludvík Vaculík while defending vigorous public argument and criticism of reputational authority.

Mým novinám

Writing Lidové noviny · c. 2001 · Journalism

The open letter asks Lidové noviny to publish dissenting views on the bombing of Afghanistan and to represent Afghan civilian victims as individual human beings.

Plebejství BBC nebo kazatelství BL?

Writing Lidové noviny · c. 2001 · Journalism

The essay disputes Jan Čulík's condemnation of Czech BBC broadcasting by comparing its practices with BBC Radio 4.

Titulek

Writing Lidové noviny · c. 2001 · Journalism

The column satirises alarmist and dull newspaper headlines while criticising editors who replace authors' titles without useful self-scrutiny.

1998 1

V moci jazyka: Nad knihou ‘Řeč komunistické moci’

Writing Lidové noviny · c. 1998 · Journalism

The review praises Petr Fidelius's analysis of communist language while questioning whether some identified mechanisms are specific to communism or general properties of language.

Undated 13

Chvála politické korektnosti

Writing Lidové noviny · Journalism

The piece defends political correctness as a natural form of language change that challenges entrenched discrimination without by itself securing equality.

Co je to civilizace

Writing Lidové noviny · Journalism

The piece distinguishes three meanings of civilisation and explains how conflating them can legitimise dehumanising responses to terrorism.

Jak vypadá vítězství terorismu?

Writing Literární noviny · Journalism

The piece argues that the metaphor of war on terrorism obscures political causes and allows fear to redefine democratic priorities.

Morálky a doktríny

Writing Lidové noviny · Journalism

The piece argues that the doctrine of preventive war and political pressure for conformity defeated moral and democratic objections to invading Iraq.

Stephen Colbert je Amerika

Writing Lidové noviny · Journalism

The review explains how Stephen Colbert's book uses an invented conservative persona to expose contradictions in American right-wing politics.

To za Saddáma nebylo

Writing Lidové noviny · Journalism

The essay argues that treating Saddam Hussein as a metonym for all Iraqi history prevents serious comparison between his regime and post-invasion Iraq.