Dominik Lukeš
Search/

Essay

"It's called MySpace for a reason": Formal and nonformal education in contact/flict

dominiklukes.net (2005–2009) · 8 February 2008

The piece examines the tension between students' private social networks and the non-formal learning that occurs within them.

Published on dominiklukes.net (2005–2009), 8 February 2008. Text as published.

In a recent meeting somebody quoted a saying by a teacher: "It's called MySpace for a reason" meaning that students may not be particularly keen on inviting the teachers into their own social-networking world. However, on the other hand, a significant amount of non-formal learning takes place in these social environments. From my recent project proposal:

Personalised learning aims to make education better respond to individual needs of all learners. One of the educational philosophies that overlap with the agenda is non-formal learning. It could be argued that much of what students do online includes learning and constitutes genuine educational achievement. Designing a MySpace theme, starting a BeBo group, moderating a forum, resolving a dispute between friends, all of these contribute to a students' transferable skills yet they remain separate from formal education. New technologies such as electronic portfolios seem to offer a possibility of integrating non-formal learning online into formal educational processes.

But how we make it count without alienating the learners and forcing them to find other spaces where they are free to learn without the formal restrictions of curricula and assessments? And, perhaps, even more importantly, without realizing that they are learning in the first place!

There seem to be several separate models for this that I experienced during three recent interviews:

  • Social networks are the students own space and we shouldn't intrude. In fact, such an intrusion raises a number of questions of ethics and law, quite apart from issues of education.
  • Social networks should serve as a model for the educational environment (Moodle, Pebblepad, Elgg) but should be largely separate from the students' own social world.
  • Social networks should be included in the curriculum in one way or another.

Both students and teachers seem to be distributed along this matrix and navigating a path between these models will be a delicate process with many cul-de-sacs explored along the way.

[Edited to add the following:]

I have since been pointed to  this interesting Demos report including a recorded discussion. I'm hoping to add more on the subject in separate posts!

Demos | Digital Curriculum - Their Space | Blog | Their Space Podcast

The way young people use technology outside school is changing and so are the ways they learn. This project, funded by the NCSL, aims to explore how schools should respond to children's informal learning with digital media such as games consoles, the internet and mobile phones.

Cite this page

Lukeš, Dominik (2008). "It's called MySpace for a reason": Formal and nonformal education in contact/flict. Dominik Lukeš. https://dominiklukes.net/writing/2008-02-08-its-called-myspace-for-a-reason

↑ ↓ moveEnter openShift+Enter sourceEsc closeAgents: the same index is at /search-index.json

Keyboard shortcuts

Single keys work anywhere except while you are typing in a box. The letters of the old site still go to the same places.

Turn off if you use speech input or stray key presses move the page. ⌘K or Ctrl+K and Esc keep working, and this list stays in the footer.

Find and switch

Open search/
Open search (Ctrl+K on Windows)⌘K
Show keyboard shortcuts?
Cycle theme: system, light, darkm
Close any dialogEsc

Go to a section

Go to Appsp
Go to Agentsg
Go to Websl
Go to Writingw
Go to Researchr
Go to Academic productivityd
Go to Resourceso
Go to Speakingt
Go to Teachinge
Go to Consultingk

Go to a page

Go to homeh
Go to abouta
Go to About this sites
Go to CVv
Go to Contactc
Go to research (old publications key)u
Tip: press Esc to close any dialog. Hover a link in the top bar to see its key.